
I debated about actually posting this, since I’ve seen it all over the place for the past day or so, but I figured maybe someone here hadn’t read it yet. Plus I had comments.
The guys over at FilmSchoolRejects compiled a top ten list of the creepiest masked horror film killers of all time. As far as lists go, it’s pretty decent. It’s got the usual suspects (Jason, Michael Myers, Leatherface) and a few surprise choices as well. I’ll also have to assume that the appearance of the characters from The Strangers (in the number 7 slot) has more to do with the film sponsoring the article than genuine creep factor (I think the masks from that film are nice, but I wouldn’t put them in my own top 10).
Now, for the editorializing. Go read the list if you haven’t already since I’m going to talk about the things that got omitted and the order of some of the listings. Go ahead, I’ll wait…
First off, the inclusion of the masks from Alice, Sweet Alice, Torso, and Dark Night of the Scarecrow are nice touches. They give the list an air of legitimacy that says “hey, we’re not just some dorks who have only seen mainstream American slasher flicks”. I’d bet money most of the people reading that list haven’t seen any of those three movies. So, kudos for attempting to broaden people’s horizons. I do have some issues with those choices and their placement, however. First off, the Alice, Sweet Alice mask should be higher. That’s a freaky mask-certainly freakier than anything in The Strangers. Second, while I love the Torso mask, I think it’s kind of plain for this list. The guys make the point that part of what’s cool about it is that you probably already have it in your closet, but I’m on the fence. Finally, I love Dark Night of the Scarecrow (which scared the piss out of me as a little kid), but I don’t know about giving it the top spot. It’s a cool mask (and the picture they have on the site doesn’t do it justice), but number one? I don’t know.
I’d have loved this list if they’d tweaked it a bit more-drop Torso and replace it with the far creepier Button Face mask David Cronenberg wears in Clive Barker’s Nightbreed. It has the same sort of functionality, but it looks about a hundred times freakier.

The other omission that bugs me is that of the owl-masked killer in Michele Soavi’s Stagefright. That mask is almost comical at first (it looks like a giant mascot head), but as the film progresses and it gets bloodier and filthier, it starts to become really unsettling.

I know I’m probably forgetting a few others that should have been included (getting old sucks), but all things considered, the FSR list is a good one. What do you think? Post some of your suggestions for the scariest horror film masks ever in the comment section.